INDEPENDENT SCHOOL MOONSHOT PODCAST

Listen and subscribe free

Raising More Money With More People and More Joy

November 16, 2026•3 min read

Listen on: Apple Podcasts - Spotify - YouTube

What would change if every family at your school saw itself as part of the story philanthropy is telling?

Tesha McCord Poe, founder and CEO of Joy-Raising, has spent her career inside independent schools as a student, parent, admissions director, advancement leader, and interim head. Seven years into running her own firm, she describes the work simply: raising more money with more people and more joy.

In this conversation, she argues that ambitious goals and an inclusive approach to fundraising are not in tension. When a school brings its whole community into philanthropy, rather than focusing only on the families who can give the most, it raises the sights on every front.

Tesha brings decades of experience on both sides of the ask, and it shows in how concrete her advice is. She explains why “give what you can, we just want participation” isn't true, why the board must make its best gift before anyone else is asked, and why a school’s top 25 donors should be compared with its top 25 most affluent families.

The conversation covers introducing philanthropy during admissions so families never feel a bait-and-switch, explaining the economics of tuition without defensiveness, and what Tesha means when she says some communities need to “decriminalize wealth.”

In the extended interview, she gets into multi-year leadership gifts, retiring student thank-you letters that cost kids their dignity, how inclusive practice shows up in a capital campaign, and how admissions and development can tell one honest story together. Heads, advancement teams, and trustees will all hear something worth bringing back to their next meeting.


Top Takeaways

1. Inclusion is a strategy for raising more, not a tradeoff against it: Tesha’s core claim is that ambitious goals and broad participation reinforce each other. A school can still hold a major donor event, as long as it can clearly and defensibly explain why that group is gathered and keep everyone’s interests in the room, even when not everyone is physically in it.

2. “Give what you can” undersells both the donor and the goal: Schools set goals based on the capacity of their communities, so telling families that any amount is fine is not quite honest. Tesha defines generosity by proportion and intention rather than the number of zeros, and the work is helping each family arrive at their best gift for a priority they genuinely care about.

3. Your top 25 donors should look like your top 25 capacity families: This is the most concrete diagnostic in the episode. If those two lists don't match—especially if whole segments of the community are missing from the first—the honest question is whether the school has truly invited and engaged them. Tesha shares the story of a donor who told her that being asked for a large gift and receiving only a thank you wasn't how things worked where he came from, and the lesson she drew was curiosity rather than judgment.

4. The board has to go first: As boards diversified in recent years, including economically, many schools never replaced the old habit of passing the hat around the boardroom. Tesha’s view is clear: trustees have the best information about the school and hold it in trust for the future, so they are best positioned to make a meaningful gift. If they are not willing to do that, the school cannot credibly ask anyone else.

5. Philanthropy belongs in the story from the first admissions conversation: Families walk past donor names on buildings during tours and then feel surprised when the annual fund appeal arrives after a large tuition payment. Tesha encourages schools to tell the story of how philanthropy has already shaped the student experience, using Hillbrook School and the donated land it was built on as her example, so giving feels like part of the community rather than an add-on.

Peter Baron

Peter Baron

Peter Baron is the founder of MoonshotOS and has spent more than 20 years serving independent schools on strategy, sustainability, and growth. Learn more at moonshotos.com.

Back to Blog